The Silent Saboteur: How Shame Affects Communication

Understanding Shame

Ever feel like you’re tiptoeing around someone, afraid to say the wrong thing? Maybe it’s a family member who is always on edge, and you don’t know why. Shame can wreck our talks and relationships. As Christians, getting a handle on shame helps us build better connections based on love and grace.

A Story of Miscommunication  

Jessica wanted to go over her husband's upcoming birthday party. “Babe, what do you want for your birthday party?” she asked.  

Her husband, Matthew, was annoyed. He didn’t like birthdays, especially his own, because they reminded him of the lack he experienced as a kid. “Whatever.”  

Jessica’s heart sank. “Just tell me what you want. It’s your party and we’re inviting a bunch of people.”  

Matthew got defensive. “I just want to relax! You’re too worried about others and having everything picture perfect.”  

Jessica felt heat rise to her cheeks. “That’s not fair. I want your input. I want to make it special for you.”  

Matthew shouted back, “Just do what you want! You’re going to do want you want anyways!”  

The talk spiraled. Jessica felt attacked even though she just wanted to make it a special celebration for her husband. Matthew accused her of being like her highly controlling mother, planting doubt in her mind, “Am I like Mom?”

“I can’t do this,” she said, leaving the kitchen.

The Impact of Shame on Communication

Shame changes how we talk and react. When it hits, our system is flooded with stress and we can get defensive and argumentative or shut down and want to hide. In Jessica and Matthew’s case, shame leads to anger, frustration, and misunderstandings.  

Jessica feels ashamed when Matthew calls her controlling and compares her to her mother. This stress clouds her thoughts and makes her defensive. On the flip side, Matthew’s defensiveness comes from his insecurities. He lashes out to protect himself instead of discussing why he doesn’t want to talk about planning his upcoming birthday party.  

Shame creates a loop of hurt feelings and missed chances for connection.  

Overcoming Shame in Communication 

When talks get tense it’s important not to take things personally. Here’s how to keep calm and connect:  

1. Know Your Triggers: Spot what makes you defensive. 

2. Schedule Hot Topic Talks: Ask to schedule a time to discuss topics you know are sensitive

so that you both can be in a better emotional and mental space for tough talks.

3. Focus on the Topic: Remember it’s not about you but the issue.  

4. Be Kind: Everyone messes up sometimes so we all need some grace.  

5. Take a Break: Step away if emotions run high and set a time to reconvene.

6. Reframe Your Thoughts: Think differently about their reactions.  

7. Consider Intentions: They might be stressed, not trying to hurt you.  

8. Ask Questions: Clarify what they mean instead of guessing.  

9. Stay Present: Use deep breaths to ground yourself and be aware when you sense yourself emotionally distancing from the awkward or uncomfortable emotions that may arise.

10. Find Common Ground: Remember your shared goals and values. You’re on the same side trying to solve a problem together. 

11. Reflect Later: Talk to God about what happened and how to improve.  

These tips help you communicate better, making room for love and grace.  

Breaking the Shame Cycle

It’s tough to talk with someone who is not ready to learn a different way to communicate because it requires vulnerability. Ultimately, your journey of healing and growth is not about changing the other person; it’s about transformation that empowers YOU to genuinely respond with kind compassion instead of defensiveness, paving the way for deeper connections and a greater sense of peace, even if you are the only one doing the work. 

If you find yourself feeling overwhelmed by strong emotions and struggling to calm down, know that you’re not alone. These feelings can sometimes feel like a pressure cooker, making it difficult to have important conversations with others. We encourage you to reach out and book a session with one of our compassionate Heart Healing facilitators. They are here to support you on your journey toward emotional relief and connection. An experiential encounter with Jesus can help release the emotional pressure so that you can have the important conversations that lead to healing difficult relationships.

Lean into Jesus’ love; you can break free from the shame cycle.

---

ACTIVATION

Journaling Prompts

1. Reflect on Shame and Scripture: Think about a recent conversation where you felt defensive or hurt. What specific comments or actions triggered those feelings? Ask Jesus, “What do you want me to know about those moments of shame? What do you want me to know about myself?”  Write about the situation and explore how understanding your worth as a child of God can help you respond differently in the future.

2. Identify Areas for Growth in Light of Faith: Consider your own journey of healing and growth. What are some areas in your life where you feel shame or insecurity? How do these feelings impact your relationships and communication with others? Write a prayer bringing these areas before God and seek His guidance for healing and growth.

3. Pray for Healthy Communication: Imagine a difficult conversation you need to have with someone in your life. How would you like to approach this conversation differently, knowing what you now understand about shame and communication? Write a prayer asking for wisdom, patience, and grace as you prepare for this conversation, and outline how you can express yourself clearly and compassionately while reflecting Christ’s love.

If answering these prompts makes you feel more agitated, we encourage you to reach out and schedule a Heart Healing session. These sessions can help you resolve hurt and pain and experience true peace and joy.